Most Popular

JOURNEY OF KHANS: Clashes, Comparisons and Collaborations

By Koral Dasgupta

salman srk hug

Salman Khan and Shah Rukh Khan, like last year, hug at Baba Siddique’s Iftar party in Bandra, Mumbai

Once again it was Iftar Party time in 2014, and once again two huge fan clubs witnessed their heroes hug each other in public.

Hands up all those readers, who feel that Salman Khan and Shah Rukh Khan have started missing each other in their personal lives. Are they playing “love you-love you not” in front of cameras, and behind the scenes they wish to say “you first”?

Well, I am no one to discuss the above-mentioned and apologies for the undue over-indulgence. 

The Salman Khan-Shah Rukh Khan tale is intriguing and fans will never have less fodder to speak in favour of or against either actors. Often a Salman Khan fan has a soft corner for SRK and vice versa. Whether you are among them or no, the journey through the careers of both actors, as elaborated henceforth, is something you would love to explore.

Both these actors started as second fiddles in the films Biwi Ho To Aisi and Deewana. While Biwi Ho To Aisi made people notice Salman Khan, Deewana gave SRK more than that. People remembered the not-so-handsome guy with a different kind of style that doesn’t give your eyes surreal pleasure but makes you sit up and pay attention anyways. 

Salman Khan on the contrary was a face that sculpted easily in the heart. He was boyish with his smiles and bohemian longings, and had large eyes to die for. That was the year 1989, which experienced intense social thrillers like Parinda, love stories like Chandni (with much senior Rishi Kapoor and Vinod Khanna), action films like Tridev and dramas like Ram Lakhan/Chalbaaz. 

Maine Pyar Kiya came as a breath of fresh air, carrying a “just out of college” theme, family issues, friendships, and a very young couple whose innocence played as much the protagonists as they themselves did.  

Salman Khan received the Best Debut Actor award that year and is known to have written an open letter to his fans, which was emotional and deep in gratitude — qualities that the actor disowned considerably in the years to follow! Maine Pyar Kiya was probably the first film which had strong elements to initiate scopes of branding. Remember the huge Mafatlal on the terrace, where the popular song Mere rang mein was shot? And the hat which had FRIENDS inscribed on it? And that jacket of Salman Khan? Bhagyashree’s kurta?

Before this film happened, hair styles, clothes, dialogues of actors did become viral among film lovers, but for the first time products got repeated visibility in the film, as if to create a very strong recall among viewers! Planned or unplanned, Maine Pyar Kiya, which released in December 29, 1989, threw open the doors towards direct marketing in a film with specific product positioning, which ironically came to be known as one of Shah Rukh Khan’s key strengths later!

Deewana (1992), which released in the same year with some blockbusters like Beta, Vishwatma, Shola Aur Shabnam, Jo Jeeta Wohi Sikandar, Bol Radha Bol and Khiladi, earned Shah Rukh Khan the Best Debut Actor Award. 

While Biwi Ho To Aisi mentions Salman Khan’s debut as a supporting cast, Shah Rukh Khan’s debut was more recognized, thanks to his successful stint with television a few years back!  Salman Khan’s “arrival” to the Indian Film Industry happened with his second film but SRK took a while to gain sufficient prominence. Though Raju Ban Gaya Gentleman was a hit, his run in the industry started only with Baazigar in 1993. Both Salman Khan and Shah Rukh Khan, after their initial high in their careers, were humbled back with a series of flops!

This is how Shah Rukh Khan and Salman Khan looked when they started off their careers

  This is how Shah Rukh Khan and Salman Khan looked when they started off their careers

Salman Khan’s relationship with the box office continued like a love-hate story, with huge success thrown among quite a number of flops. Some important titles in his career were Saajan, where he did shine bright even in the presence of the industry’s ‘stud’, Sanjay Dutt. Andaz Apna Apna, which immediately reported his budding rivalry with Aamir Khan and people rushed to the theatres for the “ek ticket do hero” deal; Hum Aapke Hain Koun became an important project in the history of Indian cinema and established Salman Khan as a prominent romantic hero of his era in 1994. 

All through this period, the other actor who is known as ‘King of Romance’ today, was busy with psychopathic characters that personified revenge, violence and ferocious obsessions! Kabhi Haan Kabhi Naa being an exception, years 1993 and 1994 explored brutality in humanness through Shah Rukh Khan in films like Baazigar, Darr and Anjaam! The actors met in 1995 in the celluloid screen for the first time with Karan Arjun!

karan arjun

  Salman and Shah Rukh in the film, Karan Arjun

Post this started a reverse journey for both actors. Shah Rukh Khan turned to romance with Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge; Salman Khan attacked the action genre with Veergati.

1995-96 was a lull period for Shah Rukh Khan when all his films failed to create jingles at the box office. The year 1997 brought him back with a romantic extravaganza which started with Yes Boss, Pardes, Dil To Pagal Hai, Kuch Kuch Hota Hai. Dil Se, in between, was a big success worldwide and was the first Indian film to enter the top 10 in the United Kingdom box office charts.

Salman Khan divided himself between action and comedy with films like Jeet, Dus, Judwaa, Biwi No. 1, Hello Brother, Pyar Kiya toh Darna Kya, etc. He did not however withdraw himself completely from the romantic genre and kept his expressive eyes active with Jab Pyar Kisi Se Hota Hai, Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam, Hum Saath Saath Hai, Kahin Pyar Na Ho Jaaye, etc.

Year 2000 was the debut year of Hrithik Roshan, and Kaho Na Pyar Hai made every existing player of Indian Film Industry stumble and take notice. While Salman Khan’s films around this time were doing quite well, Shah Rukh Khan was going through his bad days. 

Phir Bhi Dil Hai Hindustani, an ambitious project by his own production house (Dreamz Unlimited has downed shutters now) tanked and audience buried him off saying that his “boy next door” looks were obsolete in the Hrithik Roshan era! This comparison did not work against Salman Khan probably because he had always maintained a well sculpted physique and was known for his smart styling.

Salman-Khan-Shahrukh-Khan (800x600)

  Salman and Shah Rukh Khan paired up for one last time in Hum Tumhare Hain Sanam but the film didn’t release until 2002

SRK had to come back with hardcore substance, which he did with Mohabbatein, a 2000 film co-starring Amitabh Bachchan. On-screen “clash of the titans” soon got reported as “off screen rivalry”, and promoted Shah Rukh Khan as Bachchan’s most eligible, new-gen competitor!

Post 2000, when Shah Rukh Khan was going through a dream run in the industry, Salman Khan had hit the hard patch. Most of his films didn’t do well and his personal life too was inflicted with too many controversies.

The actor however, bounced back with Veer, and Dabangg marked his resurrection with a series of hugely successful films to follow soon after! At this moment, both actors are having their best understandings with the box office scores. Also, both have forayed into production houses and cricket teams. Of course Shah Rukh Khan’s business brain prompted an early response to this diversification; Salman Khan was late to catch up, may be because his sole focus at one point of time was bringing up his NGO, Being Human.

Putting their filmography to perspective, apparently Salman Khan comes from a film family; SRK is an outsider. He was not a complete novice though; since his father ran the canteen of National School of Drama, he had sufficient contacts among who’s who of the industry. In their respective journeys as actors, Shah Rukh Khan had the support of Aziz Mirza, Karan Johar, Yash and Aditya Chopra, Farah Khan throughout his career. 

Salman Khan’s journey was rather a lonely walk with only the Barjatiyas and David Dhawan partnering with him with a few films together. Much later in his career, this actor has created an umbrella of family-owned production houses – first of its kind in Indian Film Industry – where he is the hero to films created by brothers Sohail or Arbaaz Khan or brother-in-law, Atul Agnihotri. He worked with and launched many new-comers; Karishma Kapoor was his most repeated on-screen co-actor.

Shah Rukh Khan went on to pair up successfully with Kajol, Juhi Chawla, Priety Zinta, Rani Mukherjee and recently Deepika Padukone. Unlike Shah Rukh Khan’s Swades, Chak De or My Name Is Khan, Salman Khan doesn’t have “meaningful” or “substance” films in his portfolio. “I make hit films, not meaningful films” was one of his famous dialogues!

Salman Khan and Sangeeta Bijlani in an advertisement of a clothing brand

 Salman Khan and Sangeeta Bijlani in an advertisement of a clothing brand (they were dating then)

Having said that, most of the roles featuring Shah Rukh Khan are designed on the lines of a lovable boy next door, who is unapologetic about being romantic, and has a woman-of-substance to fall for and win over. Love being the softest emotion of mankind, where everyone ideally wants that one girl who makes life complete, it’s natural for audience to stick to Shah Rukh Khan and experience the dream! Salman Khan’s roles have mostly defined him as a Casanova, who audience would love to watch, have fun and cheer for; but women don’t want Casanovas as life partners and most boys don’t have the qualities to be one! Salman Khan hence got loved from a distance when the viewers poured themselves on SRK!

Salman Khan has been a model, much before his acting career had sunk into him. His endorsements basically employed his style and charisma, when Shah Rukh Khan was creating his brand and multiplying visibility through his ad films. Awards wise too, Shah Rukh Khan’s list is far bigger than that of Salman Khan, not because the later deserved any less, but relating to someone as handsome and volatile as him often became an issue.

Salman Khan’s volatility is something that every reporter has suffered; Shah Rukh Khan on the contrary has been the media’s blue eyed boy! Salman Khan’s career got inflicted with many evils which might have been the result of some immature decisions. His innate arrogance ruled over him for a very long time, till it was too late to mend. Also, they were of the stature that no level of support or sympathy could do any good. Shah Rukh Khan’s controversies were comparatively short-lived and manageable with apology statements or press conferences, or simply by living them to time!

Television helped Salman Khan in coming closer to the masses. It was only during Dus Ka Dum, that audience knew that he did more than breaking cameras and had a fine sense of humour. This shift of image helped in garnering great TRPs even later, with Big Boss. Comparatively, Shah Rukh Khan could never come back to television with equal grace that got him started in showbiz. Also this period was a generally positive phase for Salman Khan. People started talking about his generosity and charity; he gained a lot of following and respect when people got to know about the relentless effort he had put in to make his NGO, Being Human, what it is today. No one specifically knows about Shah Rukh Khan’s charitable involvements; the actor fiercely guards that aspect from public knowledge. About the generosity count, SRK reportedly makes strategic, well calculated moves rather than giving in to emotions.

Salman Khan has always been a naturally stylish person who can just carry off anything at any given occasion. He could pull off a film with a taller heroine, Sushmita Sen way back in 1999, even in a typical male chauvinist film like Biwi No. 1! It took the other heroes quite a while to come to terms with taller girls around them. Salman Khan was the 1st Indian to be voted by People magazine in 2004 as the 7th “Most good looking man in the world”.

Shah Rukh Khan never scored through his looks; in fact Juhi Chawla recalled her horror on being introduced to her hero for Raju Ban Gaya Gentleman (of course on a lighter note). Though not good-looking in the classic Bollywood sense, Shah Rukh Khan’s charm showed in his confused restlessness, witty communications, expressive body language, dimpled smiles and well-informed memory that has remained as a benchmark style swaying the nation nevertheless.

Both the Khans have one common feature: Their eyes speak a thousand words

Both the Khans have one common feature: Their eyes speak a thousand words

Shah Rukh Khan probably had known right from the beginning that his strength lied in his brain and he had to overcome his weaknesses (mannerisms, physicality, height, etc.) by exercising the gray matter. His focus on marketing himself and his films in a number of innovative ways can hence be explained. 

He was quick to understand and absorb the language of his audience, pick up on new trends and make use of every opportunity he encompassed. His business brain ran fast enough to offer or do something new, before the existing methods became obsolete! Salman Khan took a while to realize that his strength was all about his style, which came to him as a casual extension of his persona. Till then, stylish dress codes, dark glasses, fancy dialogues were every hero’s do. 

When Salman Khan started treating his casual style and screen presence seriously, he had some specific statements dedicated for his audience. He made the khaki look attractive, sunglasses hanging from the collar absolutely cool, and shaking the belt to and fro or holding a towel between the legs a dance form that was fun and easy to replicate. Audience had a new definition of “cool” and understood that “being yourself” was a unique style statement!

The journey from being Prem to Chulbul Pandey was thus not just about a name; it was a transformation from sophistication to style, attraction to attitude.

Though Shah Rukh Khan is known for his marketing talents and has significant hold on the overseas market, Salman Khan has his own achievements to name in terms of numbers and geographies. It was Maine Pyar Kiya, that opened Bollywood films to the overseas market with a dream run in the West Indies. It was dubbed in English as When Love Calls and in Spanish as Te Amo.  Hum Aapke Hain Koun! smashed records everywhere and was the first film to gross over Rs.50 crores at the Box Office. Also, it was the first film to gross over a $1,000,000 in the US market, and over 1,000,000 Pounds in the UK market. Shah Rukh Khan is more talked about in this regard because with SALES written in caps and bold in his blood, he marketed his success as well, and much better than any other actor can ever even think of replicating. 

Brand Shah Rukh Khan thus towers over everyone else in the industry, and commands greater momentum and resultant response in his favour!

 Content Copyright: The responsibility and the sole ownership of the content is of the author who has contributed the content to this blog as a friendly gesture. Please don’t copy-paste matter from this blog.To contact the writer, please visit his author page HERE. The pictures are copyrighted, please do not copy-paste them into your site.   All images of this post have been released through a PR agency for publicity and have been procured from public forums and social networking sites. Please inform us if any of the images used here are copyrighted, we will pull those images down.


6 replies »

  1. Love this article! I always admire how articles in this blog are usually always written without bias. Well done!


  2. also veer was a flop. he found success with wanted, followed by veer which was a flop… the turn around came with dabangg.


  3. correcting some facts here.
    1) Salman Khan never received best debut coz he had debuted an year back in 1988 with biwi ho to aisi. See the below video:

    2) kuch Kuch hota hai was not released in 1997 but in 1998
    3) Salman career didn’t bounce back with Veer in 2010 but with Wanted in 2009. Veer was a disaster and his only flop along with Mrs and Mr Khanna since 2009 and till date.


  4. Odd you didn’t mention Tere Naam. It was the movie that stabilised Salman’s career that was floundering at the time.

    At the end of the day, Shah Rukh will be fondly remembered for his career.


Let us know whether you liked the post or not

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.